RICHMOND GUIDE
Water heater trouble in Richmond
Historic houses often put the tank where it fit, not where a modern install would. The photo of that spot is half the service call.
Do not trust a single hardness number
Richmond’s utility publishes water-quality reports. Minerals vary with the report year and the source mix. We do not print a hardness figure here. If a quote blames scale, ask what they saw and compare it with the current report rather than a forum post.
Name the puddle
- Steady flow from the relief discharge: urgent.
- Rust at the tank seam or base: often a tank at the end of its life.
- Wet fittings above a dry tank: may be a connection.
- A closet with no pan: say so. A small leak there becomes a plaster ceiling downstairs.
Gas in an old closet
Some gas heaters sit in closets or basements with questionable air. Any rotten-egg smell means leave and follow the gas utility. Do not store paint solvents in the same closet and then wonder about odors — mention what is stored there only after you are outside and safe. Electric heaters: do not reach a panel while standing in water.
Replacement in a tight house
Ask how a new tank gets in and the old one gets out. Stairwells in the Fan are not garage doors. Ask about a pan, a drain, a permit, and whether your city or county inspects. Get exclusions in writing, including flue work.
A wet tank in July may be sweat rather than a seam. The humid summer notes show how to sort them. What changes the price of the replacement is in what changes a quote.
QUICK ANSWERS
Questions on water heaters
Should I trust a single hardness number for Richmond water?
Richmond's utility publishes water-quality reports. Minerals vary with the report year and the source mix. We do not print a hardness figure here. If a quote blames scale, ask what they saw and compare it with the current report.
Which puddle at the heater is urgent?
Steady flow from the relief discharge is urgent. Rust at the tank seam or base often means a tank at the end of its life. Wet fittings above a dry tank may be a connection. A closet with no pan should be mentioned, because a small leak there becomes a plaster ceiling downstairs.
What if I smell gas near the heater?
Any rotten-egg smell means leave and follow the gas utility. Mention solvents stored in the closet only after you are outside. For an electric heater, do not reach a panel while standing in water.
What should I ask before replacing a tank in an older house?
Ask how the new tank gets in and the old one gets out. Stairwells in the Fan are not garage doors. Ask about a pan, a drain, a permit, and whether your city or county inspects. Get exclusions in writing, including flue work.
Sources (checked October 5, 2026)
We link to these organizations for reference only. None of them is affiliated with this site.
Write it down first
The notes tool turns what you saw into a short summary you can read on the phone.
Write my service notes